Joe Weber shot an 8-under 64 Sunday morning at Riverside Golf Course and made up exactly zero ground on the leader of the Ray Fischer Amateur Championship.
When his drive sailed out of bounds on the par-5 fourth hole of the fourth and final round later in the afternoon, Weber figured he had no shot at catching Matt Tolan, who had led the Fischer after each of the first three rounds.
The dentist from Onalaska was wrong, and he is just fine with that.
A final-round 68 left the 36-year-old Weber at 19-under for the tournament. And when Tolan’s 10-foot par putt on 18 did not drop, Weber had surprisingly come from behind for the biggest victory of his amateur golf career.
“I just kept to myself, and all of the sudden on 17 I looked at the leaderboard and was like, ‘Woah!’” said Weber, who was tied with Tolan at 19 under at that point, though Tolan had a couple more holes left to play. “This means a lot. It’s really hard to win any golf tournament, but especially when you have an accomplished field like this.
“It makes this week taste a lot better after my loss in the match play.”
Weber had fought through one of the toughest amateur fields in the state to reach the Wisconsin State Golf Association’s Match Play Championship on Thursday. He lost in the championship match, 4 and 3, to Deer Park, Illinois, resident Chadd Slutzky.
Weber took solace in the fact that he was playing well—and particularly putting well—and he carried the momentum over to the Fischer in Janesville beginning Friday. He opened with a 3-under 69 on Friday and followed with a 68 on Saturday. A 7-under score was very good, but it still left him four strokes back of Tolan heading into Sunday’s 36-hole finale.
There, with pin placements ripe for scoring in the third round, Weber put together his 64—a round that included a pair of bogeys. But Tolan matched that round and threatened to lead wire-to-wire.
“I just figured Tolan was going to run away with it,” said Weber, who played collegiately at Marquette, graduating in 2006. “I thought, ‘It doesn’t really matter how many birdies I make, because he’s going to make more.’ Then I shot 8 under and he shot 8 under, so that was kind of true.
“I knew the course would play harder in the afternoon ... so I told myself to ignore the leaderboard. I hit one out of bounds on 4 and just kind of figured that was it. I wound up making bogey, and then I just kept making putts ... and it worked out.”
Weber got that shot back with a birdie on the par-5 sixth, eagled the par-5 10th and got another birdie on the par-5 14th. Even with the out-of-bounds bogey, he played the eight par 5s on Sunday in 8 under par.
That was enough as Tolan, from Eau Claire, slipped to second place for the second consecutive year at the Fischer.
After opening with rounds of 66, 67 and 64, Tolan never found his groove in the final round and suffered from several near misses down the stretch. He just missed medium-length birdie putts on 15 and 16 and was about a centimeter from chipping in for birdie on 17.
When he arrived at 18th tee, Tolan said he had not looked at the leaderboard and did not know he was tied. His drive sailed to the right and left his approach shot to the green blocked by a grove of trees. That shot wound up in a front sand trap, and Tolan blasted out to about 10 feet. His par putt attempt missed narrowly to the right.
“I wouldn’t say the wheels fell off, I just didn’t hit as quality of golf shots as I had in the first three rounds,” Tolan said. “Just didn’t make as many putts, and that’s the way it goes sometimes.
“I didn’t know where the heck I stood out there until I walked off the 18th green and found out I lost by one.
“I fell one short, and obviously, finishing second place last year, too, this is going to sting for a little bit. But I’ll be right back at it tomorrow morning, practicing and getting better. That’s the person I was born and raised to be.”
Tolan tied for second at 18 under with Fond du Lac’s Chris Colla and Lake Forest, Illinois’ John Kryscio, who each shot 67 in the final round to vault up the leaderboard.
McFarland’s Matt Davison posted the best score of the round with a 65 to tie for fifth with Milwaukee’s Nick Nelson—who tied the Riverside course record with a 62 on Sunday morning. Also in that tie for fifth was Stoughton’s Owen Butler—a Milton High graduate who won the event last year—Green Bay’s Jed Baranczyk and Sheboygan Falls’ Tyler Beeck. They were all four shots off the pace of Weber.
Sam Van Galder, the six-time champion of Janesville’s Men’s City tournament, followed up his 7-under 65 on Saturday with another 65 Sunday morning. A 73 in the final round left him in 12th at 12 under.
Butler led the way in terms of former Fischer champions. Jack Schultz, who won the event in 2017 and 2018, was 13th at 11 under. Garrett Jones, the 2007 champ, finished one spot further back at 10 under. And Matt Behm, a five-time Janesville men’s city tournament champ who won the Fischer in 2006, tied for 19th at 7 under after playing his way into the Sunday’s final group.
Tony Romo, of Burlington and the former Dallas Cowboys quarterback turned NFL color commentator, shot a final-round 75 to finish tied for 41st at 1 under for the week.
Ray Fischer Amateur Championship
At Riverside Golf Course, Janesville
Joe Weber, Onalaska 69-68-64-68—269
John Kryscio, Lake Forest, Illinois 73-65-65-67—270
Christopher Colla, Fond du Lac 74-64-65-67—270
Matt Tolan, Eau Claire 66-67-64—73—270
Matthew Davison, McFarland 75-64-69-65—273
Nick Nelson, Milwaukee 67-72-62-72—273
Owen Butler, Stoughton 68-69-68-68—273
Jed Baranzyk, Green Bay 68-69-67-69—273
Tyler Beeck, Sheboygan Falls 69-67-67-70—273
Dustin Schwab, Hartland 73-70-64-67—274
Tom Halla, Colgate 69-71-65-70—275
Sam Van Galder, Janesville 73-65-65-73—276
Jack Schultz, Whitefish Bay 68-69-67-73—277
Garrett Jones, Madison 74-66-67-71—278
Ricky Kupier, Racine 67-73-64-74—278
Max Pasher, Mequon 74-68-66-72—280
Ryonen Faris, Fond du Lac 72-72-67-69—280
Travis Engle, Kenosha 71-68-70-71—280
Adam Miller, Nekoosa 74-65-70-72—281
Matt Behm, Valders 68-69-70-74—281
Blake Wisdom, Lake Geneva 70-72-67-73—282
Maxwell Schmidtke, Sheboygan 74-70-70-68—282
Derrick Meier, Waunakee 70-73-70-70—283
Derek Hilmershausen, Wausau 69-69-72-73—283
Logan Lillehaug, Frederic 75-67-69-73—284
John Blair, Wauwatosa 73-68-71-72—284
Nick Hagen, Beloit 73-70-70-71—284
Jim Doing, Verona 75-70-72-67—284
Jakob Schroeckenthaler, Cottage Grove 70-68-69-77—284
Emmet Herb, Middleton 73-73-70-68—284
Ben Skogen, Onalaska 70-73-68-74—285
Kevin Cahill, Waukesha 71-72-7171—285
Eric Marchetti, North Chicago, Ill. 70-74-70-71—285
Zak Kulka, Beaver Dam 71-70-71-74—286
Brady Sarauer, Fond du Lac 75-68-71-72—286
Cameron Huss, Kenosha 72-67-72-75—286
Jason Zahradka, New Richmond 74-70-71-71—286
Zach Dybul, Big Bend 67-72-77-70—286
Cory Aune, Lake Geneva 70-75-72-69—286
Matthew Raab, Hartland 76-69-69-72—286
Matthew Zimmerman, Janesville 70-73-74-70—287
Tony Romo, Burlington 72-69-71-75—287
Daniel Ozga, Edgerton 73-68-73-73—287
Matt Polivka, Muskego 74-70-6974—287
Travis Pronschinske, Oconomowoc 69-72-71-76—288
James Gilmore, Middleton 72-72-73-71—288
Jack Anderson, Brookfield 71-74-72-71—288
Andrew Morrison, Edgerton 73-71-72-73—289
Nathan Boltz, Elkhorn 75-71-75-69—290
George Botts, Madison 75-71-71-73—290
Mitch Bowers, Mineral Point 71-71-73-76—291
Kyle Wille, Edgerton 73-72-73-73—291
Brian Campbell, Madison 74-72-73-72—291
Kirk Leitzen, Brodhead 74-72-72-73—291
Greg Alberte, Glendale 71-73-75-73—292
R.J. Schwalbach, Downers Grove, Ill. 69-72-77-76—294
Joe Forsting, Edgerton 72-68-70-84—294
Tom Schoewe, Sun Prairie 77-69-71-78—295
Drew Sagrillo, Mequon 71-75-71-78—295
Joseph Ploch, Oconomowoc 77-69-71-79—296
Dylan Karvala, New Berlin 67-79-77-74—297
Nathan Schwaz, Austin, Texas 71-7-79-76—298
Kevin Riley, Janesville 72-69-81-78—300
Silas Pickhardt, Madison 71-75-75-79—300
Derick Disch, Brookfield 71-73-80-80—304