Bipartisan negotiators hoping to resolve the standoff over so-called Dreamers brought their proposed immigration package to the White House on Thursday but were quickly rebuffed by President Donald Trump and GOP leaders, who advised them to broaden their group to include other lawmakers.
The swift rejection, during a meeting in the Oval Office, shows how difficult it will be for Congress to develop a legislative solution to protect some 700,000 young immigrants when Trump ends the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program in March.
The White House also made clear it does not want to include as part of the deal the Dream Act, which would expand the existing program, according to Sen. Tom Cotton, R-Ark., who took part in the meeting. Instead, the administration is seeking to protect a narrower universe of young immigrants who already have temporary DACA protections.
“I think we still have a ways to go,” White House legislative director Marc Short told reporters on Capitol Hill. “We’re pleased the bipartisan members are talking.”
The meeting comes after a federal judge this week issued an injunction halting Trump’s plans to end DACA, providing the immigrants with temporary relief. The administration plans to appeal.
More than 1,000 DACA recipients daily will face deportation in March, advocates say. They are young immigrants who were brought to the United States illegally as children but have temporary permits under DACA to work, attend school or serve in the military.
Only one Democrat, Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois—a leader of the bipartisan Senate group—was among the seven lawmakers at the noontime meeting. It included Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., another leader of the bipartisan group, and four other House and Senate lawmakers.
Cotton, who has emerged as one of the strongest proponents of White House plans to limit legal immigration, called the bipartisan senators’ proposal a “joke.”
“It’s not even a fig leaf. It’s a pine needle,” Cotton told reporters after the meeting.
When House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., told Trump that a separate group of congressional leaders was planning to continue its own discussions later Thursday, the president told them: “Go do that,” according to Cotton.
The Senate group’s proposal focused on four elements that had been agreed to during a meeting Trump convened with lawmakers earlier this week at the White House.
Their proposal centered on a deal that would offer Dream Act-like deportation protections for the young immigrants in exchange for border security measures and new limits on legal immigration through family unification visas and the diversity lottery.
Cotton said the border security measures were insufficient, though, and only included one year of funding for development of Trump’s proposed border wall, far short of the $18 billion the White House has requested from Congress. The proposal would have provided $1.6 billion for border security.
The group’s proposal also did not fully end family unification, also known as “chain migration,” and only delayed the ability of Dreamers to bring in some other family members, including their adult siblings.
Similarly, the diversity lottery was not eliminated, as some are seeking, but instead shifted its 50,000 annual visas to other immigrant groups, namely Salvadorans and others who must leave the country as Trump ends their under temporary protected status.
Republican leaders distanced themselves from the bipartisan group.
McCarthy’s group includes the four No. 2 leaders in the House and Senate, which includes Durbin, House Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer of Maryland and Sen. John Cornyn of Texas, the GOP Whip.
Cornyn told reporters any deal needs support from more than the six senators who comprised the bipartisan group.
“It’s not going to be done by just a sub group,” he said.