Highway projects/economic development hits farm family repeatedly
If you go
Two meetings are scheduled regarding a possible connector route between County G and Interstate 90/39:
-- The Rock County Board Public Works Committee meets at 8 a.m. Thursday, Sept. 13, at the Rock County Health Care Center, 3530 N. County F, Janesville. The committee will vote on its choice of routes and send that to the county board.
-- The Rock County Board will vote on the committee's recommendation during the board's meeting at 6 p.m. Thursday, Sept. 27, in courtroom H of at the Rock County Courthouse, 51 S. Main St., Janesville.
Public comment will be allowed at both meetings. People who wish to speak should arrive early to sign up.
Photo
Photo 
TOWN OF TURTLE It's never been a lot of land.
A dozen acres here, a parcel or two there, another piece for a desperately needed highway interchange or weigh station.
Since 1958, the Atkinson family has lost land for highway projects five times.
By the end of September, that number will probably go up to six.
One to five
The Atkinsons started farming in the town of Turtle in 1931. The farm is now run Robert and Alan Atkinson and their brother-in-law Scot Krebs.
They run about 3,400 acres of sweet corn, lima beans and mint—profitable crops that need irrigation. The also grow seed corn and soybeans.
In the late 1950s, the burgeoning Interstate system split the farm in half.
In the early 70s, they lost a portion of land north of Avalon Road for construction of the Avalon Road interchange.
Then Interstate 43 sliced through one of their fields. Another small loss came for an Interstate improvement over a creek.
In 2002, the family lost 23 acres to the weigh station.
Scot Krebs, who has become a defacto family spokesman, tries to be grateful for the small favors the state has bestowed on him.
"They could have taken 40 acres for the weigh station," he said. "But they cut it down to 23 and moved it a little south so we could still irrigate in that field. We were appreciative of that."
Now six
At its Sept. 27 meeting, the Rock County Board will consider a new connector between County G and Interstate 90/39.
It's designed to relieve congestion and improve safety and travel times on County G and surrounding roads, engineers said at an informational meeting Monday night.
With the I-90/39 widening project on the horizon, the connector could also serve as a bypass.
The three options include:
-- Extending Inman Parkway east from County G to Shopiere Road. Estimated cost: $4.7 million.
-- Building a connector from Shopiere Road to Creek Road, routing traffic north to Philhower Road and then over to County G. Estimated cost: $6.2 million.
-- Improving existing roads. This plan would take motorists from Shopiere Road to Cranston Road to County G. Estimated cost: $4.4 million.
The connector route is part of a $22.4 million project that would improve County G between Avalon Road and Huebbe Parkway in Beloit.
County G would remain two lanes, but the road would be reconstructed to handle trucks, and shoulders would be made wider. The Townline Road/County G intersection would also be improved.
The state would pay 70 percent of the County G project and the county would pay 30 percent.
In addition, the city of Beloit would pay for 10 percent of the Inman Parkway project.
Here's the kicker: The state's interest in the County G project is predicated on using it for a bypass route during and after Interstate construction, Rock County Administrator Craig Knutson said.
If the connector route doesn't meet the state's needs, it probably would withdraw funding for the whole, $22.4 million project, Knutson said.
If the state withholds funding, County G still would be improved, but it would be at the county's cost and "sometime in the future," Knutson said.
County Supervisor Al Sweeney said the state already has sent the county a letter saying the connector route using existing roads does not meet the project's stated purpose.
The route to the north via Philhower Road only partially meets the stated purpose of the project, Rock County Highway Commissioner Ben Coopman said at the Monday meeting.
The only choice left would run through farm fields owned by the Atkinson family and another farmer, Jerry Hahn.
Land, money and water
To say that the Atkinson family "lost" land isn't quite accurate. After all, the state paid market value for the family's property.
It's just that they never wanted to give up the land in the first place.
In a 2001 interview, Bill Atkinson, Robert and Alan's father, showed a reporter around a mint field that is now a weigh station.
As an excitable black Lab gamboled about him, Bill explained how the weigh station would cut into his field, making it impossible to grow mint, a profitable crop.
Mint needs irrigation, and center-pivot irrigation means a square field. A different shape means additional wasted money in the corners.
Bill said when people come to him about selling his land, they don't get far.
"I don't even talk to them about money," Bill said. "Money isn't going to do it."
Krebs, his son-in-law, felt the same way.
"We've always had the opportunity to sell, just haven't done it," Krebs said in an interview the same year. "Now, it's like we're being penalized for keeping it nice, not having a housing development on it."
Built-in benefits
The farmland under the proposed Inman Parkway extension isn't as good as the deep loam around the weigh station.
"It's good black soil on top, about a foot deep," Krebs said. "Then it's more gravel, and there's not a lot of water-holding capacity."
So they irrigate, although they might irrigate anyway because of what they grow.
Canning companies pay more for crops planted on irrigated land and sometimes even require it.
Irrigated vegetable crops are more uniform and still do well during drought years.
The proposed Inman Parkway extension would go right through the center of the center pivot of the irrigation.
Coopman said plans called for a pipe to be run under the road and for a new, half-circle irrigation system to be set up on the other side. The half-circle system would serve the rectangular piece left on the south of the road.
Land lost
Krebs said that his family "would just like to keep farming."
They still have plenty of acreage, but cutting up land makes fieldwork more cumbersome.
Although the weigh station debate was more than a decade ago, it feels like in happened yesterday.
"It seems like we're always fighting these issues," Krebs said. "It kinda deflates the spirit."


Sep 4, 2012 at 3:06 p.m.
Suggest removal
lovemycountry, I'll throw you an olive branch, as I suspect you are one who combines conservation with conservatism. There is a difference between my ideal world and this one. In my ideal world, we would not create incentives to burn fossil fuels (with all its costs, including the health risks of pollution and the lives of American servicemembers) by building more and more highways. In my ideal world, we would minimize the depredation of valuable agricultural land. I would prefer that money be spent on bikeways and railroads, both of which would use much less rural land. We would all be healthier, we would live closer to our jobs and have better life/work balance, and we would stop sending so much money out of our country and out of our communities.
.
In this real world, though, highways are not disappearing soon, and while I regret the loss of some land, it's fairly uncomplicated to get more. (In fact, the Leach farm was famously "land swapped" by the city to get the land that is now, I think, the youth sports complex.) The land that's not so near to the highway is less expensive, as well, because it isn't as valuable for development. So getting paid market value for an acre there might get you (oversimplified) an acre and a half or two acres elsewhere.
.
I'm not sure why you're such a pessimistic declinist about America, but I'm sure that our population is not going to shrink anytime soon, and at some point we just have to implement things that the public needs. At least, in a sense, the highway money is being spent more or less locally, and will help create a foundation for future robust economic activity in the region.
Sep 4, 2012 at 11:28 a.m.
Suggest removal
Follow the money, the impetus for these "needed" highway extensions usually comes from the road builders - especially a large one in Beloit.
Sep 4, 2012 at 11:05 a.m.
Suggest removal
It's called progress, get over it. Maybe they should cry to their buddy Scooter, I'm sure he'll fix the problem for them, would give him a much needed break from screwing over the working class.
Sep 4, 2012 at 8:34 a.m.
Suggest removal
Apparently Sigma tied a knot in his years ago and doesn't know how to undo it.
Sep 4, 2012 at 6:16 a.m.
Suggest removal
ozzman99 - When we have TV shows that promote having 19 kids that is a problem. Also the birth rate has not stayed the same....mayby by percentages, but the actual number now compared to 50 years ago... if it continues to increase at that percentage we're doomed in 50 years. We'll have to build another city on top of all the cities. In 1950 there was about 152 million people, Today there is roughly 312 million.
Sep 3, 2012 at 5:07 p.m.
Suggest removal
I feel for the Atkinson family, what a pain to deal with. Having to deal with it a 6th time would almost be a boiling point. I love the minty fresh smell out there when they are harvesting the mint. For all you saying that the scale is NEVER open I would disagree with you. I drive truck up and down the interstate in rock county every day and pretty much every day it is open and collecting a lot of money from all the regulations the federal government keeps making up. They have even recently added a few more camera systems to check things on the fly. Although I have never had to step foot IN the scale, from what I heard it is a very technologically advanced system.
Sep 3, 2012 at 4:33 p.m.
Suggest removal
Sigma the only cause for population increase in this country involves immigrants with high fertility rates and people generally living longer. The native born birth rate has stayed flat for a few decades now
Sep 3, 2012 at 12:22 p.m.
Suggest removal
If we dont start doing something about the out of control population increase its only going to get worse. But even though it is the true demise of everything, its absurd to talk about human reproduction in that manner. If things continue to grow I'll be able to see in my lifetime the last farm field turned into a parking lot, housing project, or an interstate.
Sep 3, 2012 at 11:39 a.m.
Suggest removal
HOOTERS - Thank you very much - that is what I wanted to know. Do you know how many homes were torn down by Storrs lake due to the Hwy 26 expansion? Thanks again.
Sep 3, 2012 at 11:37 a.m.
Suggest removal
BILLNEWBIE - You raised an EXCELLENT point. I had not read the story about the Milton Gas / convenience story until your comment. I would agree with you on that one. You would think(And HOPE!)that the state would be considerate about the businesses along or near the new Hwy 26 so each businesses could prosper. I get gas at that station often when my job takes me out of town. The guy that owns that station has a very positive business that contributes much to the area tax base.
Sep 3, 2012 at 11:33 a.m.
Suggest removal
I remember a co-worker talking about losing his new home (near Storr's Lake) when they were putting in that bypass. He made it sound like he was making a killing on the sale of his home/property to the state. He also was allowed to gut out and sell everything in his new home. Of course, I realize that this always isn't the case and many people get screwed in such a deal.
Sep 3, 2012 at 10:57 a.m.
Suggest removal
I continue to see one large missed point it this story: When government takes land away from farmers for the convenience of others (Highways, a weigh station that isn't used)and disrupts or destroys a farmer's ability to grow crops - in this case FOOD crops. Why doesn't anyone understand this simple question Where is our food going to come from? This land isn't replaceable. But it's seems to be much more important that the "haves" trim 3.5 minutes off the trip to anywhere, than give the farmer the continuing ability to grow the food we eat.
Sep 3, 2012 at 10:54 a.m.
Suggest removal
Ive never seen the weigh station open either.
-
And why do they need such a big median in between the 2 lanes of the interstate? Huge waste of space.
Sep 3, 2012 at 8:55 a.m.
Suggest removal
My, what a difference there is in the tenor of the comments here in comparison with the story of the gas station/McDonald's in Milton. I guess that the empathy well of some is so shallow that while they can find it in their hearts to ladle out a little for farmers and home owners, the supply is so short that business people and their employees can take a long walk off a short pier.
Sep 3, 2012 at 8:53 a.m.
Suggest removal
The state should pay market value plus. The plus being their profits on this land per year times 20years or maybe 30 years. This, would be a fair price given the lost profits on this land.
Sep 3, 2012 at 5 a.m.
Suggest removal
I have a question about the highway 26 expansion. Does anyone remember how many fairly new homes had to be moved or destroyed near STORRS LAKE, Milton because of the HWY 26 project????
Sep 3, 2012 at 4:46 a.m.
Suggest removal
Just what u don't need is a Ref. berween LOVEMYCOUNTRY & JANESVILLIAN But here goes anyway -- I can see both of your points and they are very well stated. I travel that portion of the interstate often and feel the extension is important. At the same time - I have much empathy for the farming family and would like to see them make LOTS of money from this. I would like to see them receive MORE than the market value for the land & the continous inconvenience on their livelihood that is caused by all of these projects. They deserve a lot more money than what the state is giving them.
Sep 3, 2012 at 1:34 a.m.
Suggest removal
Sorry, lovemycountry, can't hear you through the crinkling of your tinfoil hat. But it doesn't sound like you know me one bit. I do hope you have enough government cheese stored up in your abandoned mine, though.
Sep 2, 2012 at 10:07 p.m.
Suggest removal
janesvillean is still living the illusion the U.S. is in continuous economic growth, and that we need yet more highways. Instead, he will see a decades long global collapse brought on by big government debt, central banks, and fiat currency. And janesvillean will cheer all of these destructors on to the end.
Sep 2, 2012 at 4:54 p.m.
Suggest removal
I have NEVER seen that weigh station open.
What a waste of money, power move by the State.
Sep 2, 2012 at 4:43 p.m.
Suggest removal
Yes, the topsoil is wonderful, and it can be awkward to have to plow/irrigate an irregular plot, but these are hardly extraordinary concerns for farmers. They live along a major Interstate highway that serves a heavily-traveled corridor. Both Beloit and Janesville continue to grow.
.
I do hope the County Board is sensible and approves the extension of Inman Parkway. They need to think about the transportation needs of 2020 and beyond. In a generation people will wonder why the heck they didn't just put it straight through. (Really, much of the Town of Beloit is a testament to the NIMBY factor in frustrating anything approaching logical urban planning. It's time to lose that reputation.)
Before you post a comment, consider this:
Note: GazetteXtra.com does not condone or review every comment. Read more in our User Policy AgreementPost Comment
Commenting requires registration.