UW’s restrictions on transfer irk former Badger
Uthoff’s former AAU coach, Jamie Johnson, said Wednesday that Uthoff recently told Wisconsin officials he intends to transfer and submitted a list of approximately 25 schools he hoped to talk to. Johnson said Wisconsin denied permission to more than half of the programs on Uthoff’s list.
Johnson said Iowa’s “Mr. Basketball” from 2011 is appealing in hopes that the school will lift its restrictions.
“He’s hopeful,” Johnson said. “I think he’s surprised at what has transpired.”
Johnson said Uthoff also will visit Creighton, one of the schools approved by Wisconsin.
Wisconsin officials did not respond to a request for comment from The Associated Press, and Uthoff did not immediately respond to a text message.
The 6-8 forward told an Iowa-based high school sports website, metrosportsreport.com, that Badgers coach Bo Ryan has placed every Big Ten and ACC school, plus Iowa State and Marquette, on the list of schools that can’t contact him. According to the site, Uthoff said he would consider making an appeal to the NCAA if his appeals to Wisconsin don’t work.
“We’ll see. I might,” he told the site.
NCAA rules allow a player to transfer, requiring them to sit out a year in most cases. But as Uthoff’s situation shows, the process can be more complicated than simply finding a new school and filling out some forms. According to the NCAA’s website, most transfers also require a “permission-to-contact” letter from the current school to the new school.
According to a student athlete handbook posted on Wisconsin’s website, a player who intends to transfer must make a written request to the school’s director of compliance for permission to speak to another institution or use the transfer exception. A coach may deny permission, and the student-athlete can appeal.
“Appeals related to the denial, by a coach, of a student-athlete’s request to contact another institution or to use the one-time transfer exception, begin with a written request to the sport administrator for the student-athlete’s team,” the handbook says.
If the sport administrator upholds the coach’s decision, the student-athlete can appeal to athletic director Barry Alvarez. If Alvarez upholds the decision, the student-athlete can make a request to the chair of the athletic board for an appeal committee hearing that will determine “whether the athletic director’s decision was reasonable.”
According to the handbook, the appeal committee’s decision is final and not subject to further review.
Uthoff’s dispute with Wisconsin took an odd turn Wednesday when The Gazette of Cedar Rapids, Iowa reported that school officials had misplaced a letter he was required to file to appeal the decision.
Uthoff told the AP that he had a friend deliver the letter to the office of associate athletic director Justin Doherty before the deadline and a secretary put it in his mailbox.
“Apparently, he didn’t check his mailbox,” Uthoff said.
Doherty said the person who dropped off Uthoff’s letter at his office last week didn’t explain its importance or time-sensitive nature. After Doherty and other athletic department staff met with Uthoff to figure out what had happened, Doherty looked in his mailbox and found the letter.
Now Uthoff will meet with Doherty on Thursday regarding his appeal.
“Jarrod is going to be afforded the normal, NCAA-described appeal process,” Doherty said.
Johnson wonders why players don’t have more freedom to switch schools when there are few such restrictions on coaches and athletic directors.
“I guess I don’t understand how ADs can job-hop and coaches can job-hop … It seems like there’s a double standard out there,” Johnson said.
And Johnson doesn’t understand why Wisconsin might be worried about Uthoff going to another marquee program.
“If you end up playing (against) him, just try to beat that team,” Johnson said.
Johnson said Uthoff wants to transfer because he felt he didn’t fit in with the Badgers’ style of play.
His advice to Uthoff this time around?
“Take your time this time,” Johnson said. “Don’t rush into anything.”
Johnson, a coach with the Iowa Barnstormers program, calls Ryan and assistant Greg Gard “good guys” and says he wouldn’t necessarily discourage future recruits from considering UW.
“At the same time, I hope cooler heads prevail,” Johnson said.