Rodgers fights off Favre legacy to build his own
Then, he heard his name. In a matter of seconds, he went from draft day disappointment to Brett Favre's backup.
A lot of baggage to carry up to the Frozen Tundra.
"I never thought it was baggage," Rodgers said. "I was happy someone picked me."
The Packers are happy, too.
Despite skeptical fans and a less-than-welcoming Favre, Rodgers took over the starting job three years ago. This year, he led the Pack to the Super Bowl and is now as revered in Green Bay as the guy who once wore No. 4 — the quarterback they once said was irreplaceable.
"It was a difficult situation," Rodgers said. "It was tough to stand up every day in front of the media not knowing what questions were coming at me and how the fans were going to react that day in practice. But the whole time, the organization stood by me and they told the truth, and I told the truth, and we moved on together."
Those who knew him, had studied his game and his slow, steady rise through the sport could see this coming.
One of the most savvy moves Rodgers made was to contact Steve Young, who went through a very similar scenario in San Francisco when he waited behind Joe Montana in the 1990s.
Young's advice: "You have to take a laser focus on the opportunity to be on a good team and play good football and not worry about the other stuff. You try to forget about all the things that make it hard. If you go there, you'll find yourself doing the human-nature thing and trying to get people to understand how hard it is. That never works. You never want to let that happen."
Rodgers comes by that credo honestly. His whole career has been about overcoming one obstacle or another.
He was a record-setter at Pleasant Valley High School in Chico, Calif., but at 5-foot-10, 165 pounds, didn't get a serious look from the major colleges. So, he stayed in the area, enrolled at Butte Community College and immediately won over a group of players in their 20s who had as much experience in the school of hard knocks as on the football field.
"I think Aaron had a unique way of kind of reaching to a different cast of characters," said Butte coach Jeff Jordan, who was Rodgers' position coach back then. "Whether it was guys who were there because of academics or guys who were raised on the streets or spent time in the military. It doesn't mean he hung with them, but he accepted them. That's kind of why people maybe gravitated toward him, even though he was this young, 18-year-old, skinny little baby-faced boy coming in."
After throwing for 28 touchdowns in one season at Butte — along with starting a growth spurt that would see him add four inches and 50 pounds — Rodgers made his way to Cal, where he worked with coach Jeff Tedford. In two years there, Rodgers went 14-4 as a starter, threw for 5,469 yards and, for a long time in the lead-up to the 2005 draft, was being touted as a possible No. 1 pick.
Reputations change, though, and when his favorite team growing up, the Niners, used the first pick on another quarterback, Alex Smith, Rodgers' slide down the board began.
Picking at No. 24, the Packers hadn't spent any time in the offseason considering the possibility that Rodgers would fall down to their spot. But about 10 days before the draft, they saw his stock was still fading. They started doing some homework. They realized they would almost have to take him if he fell that far. It wasn't so much that they needed a quarterback, it was that Rodgers was such a bargain at that point, he'd be almost impossible to pass up.
The pick, of course, was not all that popular — not with Favre still in the late part of his prime and showing no signs of the retirement-unretirement game he'd saddle the Packers and others with a few years down the road.
Then again, many other talented quarterbacks — Mark Brunell, Matt Hasselbeck and Kurt Warner — had been brought in as Favre's backup, spent a few years, then moved on.
"In some ways, sitting for three years and then playing is helpful," said general manager Ted Thompson, who was questioned when he made the pick, then criticized when he traded Favre to make way for Rodgers to become the starter. "That's the way it was back in the day. You always brought quarterbacks in and you developed them for about two or three years before you actually played them. That's hard to do anymore."
Indeed, in the salary cap era, finances make it hard to justify spending first-round money for a player to sit on the bench, even if he is a quarterback who needs time. Add the fact that shortly after Rodgers was chosen, Favre said in an interview that it wasn't his job to mentor his understudies, and it was clear that this was not going to be the most comfortable situation.
"The best way to describe it was, we were teammates the first year," Rodgers said in a 2008 interview. "It was a very business relationship. But I was kind of in his hip pocket. My biggest thing was, if we're not going to be friends yet, which is fine, I'm still going to be in his hip pocket until he tells me to get lost."
Meanwhile, determined to make the situation work, Rodgers reached out to Young, who says not much has changed in the NFL in the 15 years between his odyssey and Rodgers'.
"The exact circumstances may have changed but the challenge is the same," Young said. "I think he's been remarkable not taking the bait on anything and focusing on what really matters, then going out and doing it. Maybe people want more drama and intrigue. But he hasn't given it to them. Good for him."
With his focus squarely on football, Rodgers has done nothing but get better since getting his first chance in, of all places, the Super Bowl city of Dallas. Favre went out with a concussion that day in 2007 and Rodgers completed 18 of 26 passes for 201 yards and a touchdown as his backup.
By the next season, Favre was gone, Thompson was being cast as a villain and Rodgers was on the road to becoming an elite quarterback.
"I always just looked at Aaron Rodgers as a quarterback who's really developing and delivering on time," coach Mike McCarthy said. "I don't look at one big hurdle he had to overcome. He stayed true to his craft, true to the fundamentals, became an expert in offense. He has the ability to run the whole offense at the line."
To his coach, his receivers, his mentors, that's what stands out about Rodgers.
"He'll call me at 7:30 in the morning and talk about something he saw on the tape," receiver James Jones said. "Or we'll be standing in the huddle on 3rd and 2 and he'll tell us exactly what the defense is going to do and they do it."
His stats, not surprisingly, have reflected this mastery of the playbook. Rodgers threw for 3,922 yards and 28 touchdowns with only 11 interceptions in the regular season. He has completed 71 percent of his passes in the postseason and put in what Mike Ditka called the best postseason performance he'd ever seen by a quarterback with a 366-yard, three-TD game in the 48-21 win over Atlanta.
Of course, many experts measure the real greatness of a quarterback by Super Bowl victories. With a win Sunday, Rodgers will be even with Favre.
Young expects it to happen. He said Rodgers — with his expertise at reading defenses — has gotten to a point that only the very best reach.
"Very few quarterbacks dictate terms and he's becoming one of those guys," Young said. "Very few people own it like that. He has the ability to make it a very long day for a defense. I think Sunday could be a real revelation for a lot of people about who, exactly, Aaron Rodgers is."
Last updated: 4:34 pm Thursday, December 13, 2012