Studer Year 2: Signs of progress
JANESVILLE The Janesville School District is starting its second year of a new way of doing business. Staff calls it the Studer process.
Part of the process involves doing something that might not come natural to a boss: Listening to what employees have to say and striving to make those employees happy in their jobs.
That’s why the Studer process calls for regular surveys to gauge staff satisfaction. The district recently completed its second survey, and the results show improvement from the first one, done in spring 2008.
Most schools saw most of their ratings go up, but Jackson and Washington elementary schools saw lots of change in the negative direction.
Jackson Principal John Walczak is new this year, while Washington’s principal, Scott Garner, is in his second year, noted Superintendent Karen Schulte.
“What I liked about both of those principals is they didn’t make excuses for those numbers going down but dug in with their staffs right away” to find solutions, Schulte said. “I felt the principals took that very seriously.”
The surveys are not the only way principals are evaluated. They also must answer for test scores and truancy statistics, among other measures.
Parker High School, where Steve Schroeder replaced Dale Carlson as principal last fall, showed marked improvement on the survey.
“That tells me that possibly Parker is very happy with their new principal,” Schulte said.
Schulte noted the middle schools improved quite a bit, too.
“I see our middle school principals as really working together, learning together, and they’re just a really great team,” Schulte said.
Schulte also singled out Lincoln and Roosevelt as schools where the principals embraced the process and reaped improvements.
Schulte said she is not concerned about any of the principals’ dedication to improvement. And it’s too early in the process to discipline anyone for survey results, she said.
“I feel we’re all in this together. We’re all learning together and all striving hard to be high performers,” Schulte said.
That includes Principal Marlene Novota at Harrison Elementary, which had some of the lowest scores in last year’s staff survey.
For instance, Novota got a 2.88 last year for the question “My principal demonstrates genuine concern for my welfare.” That’s on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being the most positive.
This year, Novota got a 3.45 for that same question in the new survey.
A 3 is considered average. Schulte said the goal is to achieve a 4, with anything above that being exceptional.
Novota noted that Harrison improved in most of the other questions, too.
“That, to me, speaks volumes for us and that we’re heading in the right direction,” she said.
Novota said she has embraced the Studer techniques of sending out notes of praise and thanks and “rounding” with every staff member regularly.
Rounding means meeting with the employee and asking specific questions, such as: Who has done something lately that deserves praise? What’s working? What do you need to do your job?
Rounding keeps lines of communications open in both directions, Novota said.
Novota said she and her staff also have taken steps to make Harrison feel more like an extended family. For example, “good news boards” in the classrooms and in the teachers’ lounge allow students and teachers to announce positive things that happened in their lives.
The boards provide a sense of community, “so everybody is in tune with each other, not only in their professional life but in their personal life,” Novota said.
“I had a dance competition and got three golds!” one student posted on a board.
“I got a new dog,” another wrote.
Teachers also hold morning “community circles” that allow students to talk about anything that they need to express.
Teachers also have boards where they tell of good things their students are doing. One note posted in a hall said: “(Student’s name) has done a nice job of staying positive, even when facing a challenge.”
“I am very happy about it,” Novota said of the improved scores. “Harrison is a good school, a great place for me to be. We have great students, great parents, a lot of support.”
She added: “I’m not afraid of change because I think change means growth.”
Principals also fill out satisfaction surveys for all the departments, from food service to maintenance to student services. Department heads were required to discuss their scores with principals this year, to discuss ways to improve, Novota said.
Another staff survey is planned before school lets out in June, and a second parent-satisfaction survey also will be done this spring. State test scores are scheduled to be released this week.
Leadership scores
The Janesville School District staff satisfaction survey combines a series of questions to show how well each school does in “building leadership,” effectively giving an overall score to each principal. Here are the building leadership scores from the first survey in 2008 to the second one in 2009:
School 2008 2009
District 3.59 3.96
Elementary 3.66 3.96
Adams 4.15 4.44
Harrison 3.06 3.32
Jackson* 3.82 3.7
Jefferson** 3.53 3.89
Kennedy** 3.95 4.42
Lincoln 3.3 4.12
Madison** 3.37 3.55
Monroe 3.93 4.16
Roosevelt** 3.33 3.92
Van Buren 3.86 4.21
Washington 3.84 3.75
Wilson* 3.78 3.89
Middle 3.67 4.18
Edison 3.56 4.13
Franklin 3.67 4.08
Marshall* 3.78 4.31
High 3.25 3.79
Craig 3.55 3.7
Parker* 2.92 3.89
* Indicates a new principal since the first survey was taken.
** Indicates principals retiring in June.

Apr 30, 2009 at 7:06 p.m.
Suggest removal
Trish-It wasn't negative-Mr. Garner is making changes finally that needed to be done to our staff- What changes do you propose? Suggestions go a lot farther than criticism. Isn't it about the children? He is adored by them by the way-would sleep on a roof??
Apr 27, 2009 at 9:11 p.m.
Suggest removal
Most schools saw most of their ratings go up, but Jackson and Washington elementary schools saw lots of change in the negative direction.
Enough said.
Apr 27, 2009 at 8:11 p.m.
Suggest removal
Rip me all you want is TRUE CLASS! That comment says it all! Let's get back to the topic Mr.Garner is doing a fabulous job at Washington and the community at large. He has and continues to do a fantastic job-volunteers many hours after school to help students and parents.
Apr 27, 2009 at 6:50 p.m.
Suggest removal
Actually, I did have the "privilege" of having a child in a school that he was employed at. Anyhow, before you start talking about me needing a English class, perhaps you should take a spelling class. PRIVILEGE..not priveledge.
Rip me all you want. I really don't care.
Apr 27, 2009 at 6:03 p.m.
Suggest removal
Anyone who is the least bit suprised that Mr.Garner "even got the job" and words it like that tells me a couple things, first they obviously did not pass english class, and second has not had the priveledge of working with him or having a child in his school.
Apr 27, 2009 at 3:30 p.m.
Suggest removal
I believe what "they" were thinking when Scott Garner was hired, was something like...With an exemplary track record like he has, along with his expertise in building rapport and fostering relationships with students, parents, and staff, this Garner fellow is a no brainer!
Apr 27, 2009 at 12:25 p.m.
Suggest removal
I am not the least bit surprised that Washington School Staff is not happy with Scott Garner. I can't even believe he got the job, honestly. What were they thinking?
Apr 26, 2009 at 6:57 p.m.
Suggest removal
I think it is a shame that we are focussing on a survey that was done months ago, when we have student achievement data that will reflect how our students are doing, not whether or not the staff is happy. Mr.Garner has been a godsend to Washington Elementary School. We are lucky to have him!
Apr 26, 2009 at 2:30 p.m.
Suggest removal
The problem also is the nature of the questions and the number of staff members answering questions. Elementary principals are at a clear disadvantage with a smaller staff. One or two staff members could have issues with the principal (which may or may not deal directly with his/her performance, ie: grudge holding) and that could throw off the results. I find this Studer thing very troubling for a school setting. It seems more business oriented. Our schools are not profit making businesses, they shouldn't be treated as such. The number one concern should be what is best for our students.
Apr 26, 2009 at 2:20 p.m.
Suggest removal
have concerns: Based on the chart in the paper this morning, the staff responded less favorably on 28 of the 40 survey question versus 2008. Compare that to Kennedy, Lincoln, Adams, Edison, Franklin, and Marshall schools where 100% of the surveys were at or greater than 2008. Based on statistics there is a problem. I'm not saying it's with the staff. I'm saying the staff is clearly stating there is a problem.
Apr 26, 2009 at 2:11 p.m.
Suggest removal
localmatters, that is a very unfair statement to make. You most certainly can not know EVERY staff member at Washington that well. I know some, and they do not share your evaluation of the situation. Why don't you focus on your thoughts, let others give their's. Do you have a specific complaint that you know of first hand? I think Mr. Garner is doing a very nice job connecting with students, parents and staff. Have you ever slept on a rooftop in the rain because grade school students raised money for a good cause? Mr. Garner did. That is just one small example, there are many more.
Apr 26, 2009 at 1:08 p.m.
Suggest removal
Washington has certainly regressed (in the eyes of staff).
Apr 26, 2009 at 11:56 a.m.
Suggest removal
Well, "something that might not come natural to a boss" is what a trained corporate boss ought to be doing. In the Fortune 500 firms I've worked, there were bad apples of course, but most of them did understand their role as at least to some degree facilitating their employees. This is just modern management philosophy.
.
I do hope the survey does in fact reflect value that the district is getting from the Studer Group.
Apr 26, 2009 at 7:22 a.m.
Suggest removal
Congratulations, Principals - You have worked hard! Now, to hell with your pay raises!
Apr 26, 2009 at 3:11 a.m.
Suggest removal
WAY TO GO MRS.GRANT!!!!(ADAMS)
Before you post a comment, consider this:
Note: GazetteXtra.com does not condone or review every comment. Read more in our User Policy AgreementPost Comment
Commenting requires registration.