Wisconsin lawmakers are considering a bill to bar public access to recordings of 911 emergency calls. These audio recordings would be replaced with transcripts.

As a broadcast news professional, I understand that 911 calls may be painful for families of victims. That’s why a lot of thought already goes into deciding whether and how to use these recordings.

At WMTV NBC15 in Madison, where I work, these decisions are made on a case-by-case basis. We do not sensationalize 911 calls. We do not air these recordings just because we have them.

In every case, we ask a series of questions: Does the 911 audio have news value? Does it help viewers understand the story? Does it expose wrongdoing or show appropriate response?

We also ask: Are we exploiting the caller or the situation? Is the 911 audio too graphic?

Often these recordings are aired because they shed light on how public safety calls are handled. In November 2008, the Dane County 911 center received two calls regarding a disturbance at a Madison park. But no officers were sent. An hour and a half later, one person was discovered dead.

In this case, the 911 recordings revealed that the center violated policy requiring a response to multiple calls reporting the same problem.

Dane County’s 911 center also took heat for its handling of a call from Brittany Zimmermann, a UW-Madison student murdered in her downtown Madison apartment in 2008. The dispatch center received a call from Zimmermann’s cell phone at about the time the murder was taking place. But the 911 operator couldn’t determine there was an emergency before the call was disconnected, so officers weren’t dispatched.

Police who reviewed the call say the operator missed significant background sounds, including a scream and sounds of a struggle. The operator was disciplined, but the call has still not been released because the case remains unsolved.

A transcript would not tell the whole story of what the operator heard or should have heard. If this were to become the new standard, it would leave the public in the dark in important situations.

Earlier, the 911 center released a recording of the call made by Zimmermann’s fiancé when he found her body. My station decided against using it on the air. Instead, the audio clip was posted on our Web site so people could decide for themselves if they wanted to hear it.

Under the proposed new law, even this would not be allowed.

Some 911 calls shed light on the appropriateness of police responses. In March 2004, a man with a knife attacked employees at a day care center in Madison. The suspect then barricaded himself in a room with young children. Police officers shot and killed him. The 911 calls affirmed that the officer tried to get the man to cooperate, supporting the official conclusion that the use of force was justified.

In this case, it was an important part of the story. Transcripts would not have let the public hear how little time officers had to make a life and death decision.

In a recent interview with the Appleton Post-Crescent, Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen expressed concern was for victims and the families who are under duress when they make calls, and the effect making the calls public would have on them.

We in the media agree these are important concerns, and we always keep them in mind in our coverage. But I believe the public’s right to know vital information about the public safety process is at times more important.

GazetteXtra.com does not condone or review every comment. Read more in our Commenter Policy Agreement

  • Keep it clean. Comments that are obscene, vulgar or sexually oriented will be removed. Creative spelling of such terms or implied use of such language is banned, also.
  • Don't threaten to hurt or kill anyone.
  • Be nice. No racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person.
  • Harassing comments. If you are the subject of a harassing comment or personal attack by another user, do not respond in-kind. Use the "Report comment abuse" link below to report offensive comments.
  • Share what you know. Give us your eyewitness accounts, background, observations and history.
  • Do not libel anyone. Libel is writing something false about someone that damages that person's reputation.
  • Ask questions. What more do you want to know about the story?
  • Stay focused. Keep on the story's topic.
  • Help us get it right. If you spot a factual error or misspelling, email newsroom@gazettextra.com or call 1-800-362-6712.
  • Remember, this is our site. We set the rules, and we reserve the right to remove any comments that we deem inappropriate.

Report comment abuse